Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
Hollyleaf Vs Stonefur by ElusiveBlaze Hollyleaf Vs Stonefur by ElusiveBlaze
To everyone saying that Hollyleaf is an original character and did everything she thought was right.

(BTW, this is mostly a pro-Stonefur post XD)

I noticed many similarities between the stories of Hollyleaf and Stonefur.

Stonefur is like Hollyleaf, but done right.

Stonefur went through worse scenarios, but ended up better.

Stonefur is one of the best characters in the series.

But why don't as many people like Stonefur than Hollyleaf?

I am stumped.

(I literally drew this in half an hour XD)

EDIT:

Guys, Hollyleaf is not a badass.
She ran away from her problems. That is the weakest and most pathetic thing someone can do.

Stonefur is a badass. He faced his problems head-on.

You like Hollyleaf because of her tragic past? Stonefur's is miles more tragic if that's all you look for in a character!
Add a Comment:
 
:iconkwitterpwea:
KwitterPwea Featured By Owner 2 days ago  Hobbyist Digital Artist
HOLLYBitch
Reply
:iconivypool123456:
ivypool123456 Featured By Owner Jan 22, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i like them both :) but u have a point....
Reply
:iconredkitty50:
Redkitty50 Featured By Owner Dec 10, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I know you will hate me for this but,

1. Hollyleaf stopped a war between Clans twice (Book 1 and Book 2 of third series).
2. Stormfur (or Mistyfoot I dunno) tried to kill Bluestar. Even though he didn't know it was his mom, he was trying to KILL a leader! 
3. Hollyleaf redeem a bit (I said) by helping ThunderClan to fight off WindClan in book 5 serie 4
4. She forgives Leafpool before Lionblaze could do it (and he was the most hypocrite in my opinion)
5. Firestar murdered Tigerclaw and Yellowfang murdered her son (twice) so it means that Hollyleaf isn't automaticly evil

I know that you hate her, but it's some details I want to add. Again, I don't wanna be rude or force you my opinion. Thanks for reading.
Reply
:iconrosythefoxluv:
rosythefoxluv Featured By Owner Nov 22, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
OH WHAT ABOUT BLUESTAR,GREYSTRIPE AND BRAMBLECLAW HMM but good point
Reply
:iconmieathederp:
Mieathederp Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
but bloostar and brambleclaw was here...
Reply
:iconrosythefoxluv:
rosythefoxluv Featured By Owner Nov 22, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
who was stonefur i forgot was that bluestars kit if so i wuv u stonefur
Reply
:iconlast-cat-standing:
Last-Cat-Standing Featured By Owner Edited Nov 9, 2015  Hobbyist Artist
YES!! Thank you for making this a thing Blaze owo
Reply
:iconhopelight2:
Hopelight2 Featured By Owner Nov 6, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I don't mind Hollyleaf. I didn't like her before The Last Hope because she was a dick and always on about the warrior code even though she and her litter mates broke a few rules, but for good. In the Last Hope, I liked her then because she did give up her life to save Ivypool and Thunderclan.

Now Stonefur is my favorite Half-clan Male. He always will no matter what. 
Reply
:iconxxtrapqueenxx:
XxTrapQueenxX Featured By Owner Oct 16, 2015  Student Traditional Artist
I agree. She's a hypocrite. She killed Ashfur for no apparent reason, and then she tells the whole clans about it herself? I, personally, choose Ashfur and Stonefur over her.... 
Reply
:iconwindblade2313:
WindBlade2313 Featured By Owner Oct 13, 2015
Yes, Thank you for this. I never really liked Hollyleaf, though I couldn't put my finger on why except for obvious reasons. Now I know why I always had a dislike to her. She was really a bitch sometimes.
Reply
:iconwhiskey-spaniel:
Whiskey-Spaniel Featured By Owner Aug 25, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
PREACH IT PLEASE OMFG
Holly is a bitch imo
Reply
:iconlightningdraco:
LightningDraco Featured By Owner Aug 17, 2015
I think it's because she killed Ashfur.  I don't like Ashfur, but I don't think death is what he deserved, despite his stupid actions.  He deserved to be banished after trying to kill Firestar.
Reply
:iconmieathederp:
Mieathederp Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I think they might not have known Ashfur helped Hawkfrost kill him, making them think it was all Hawkfrost's fault, which is why they didn't banish him. Sorry If they did know, I didn't read the books for a while.
Reply
:iconlightningdraco:
LightningDraco Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016
I agree.  But it makes me wonder about his "trying to kill Squirrelflight's kits" thing.
Reply
:iconmieathederp:
Mieathederp Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Eh, I guess revenge for leaving him.
Reply
:iconlightningdraco:
LightningDraco Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016
A very stupid way to get revenge from someone who rejects you.  I wonder if the other cats knew about the incident though...
Reply
:iconmieathederp:
Mieathederp Featured By Owner Jan 5, 2016  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Most likely.
Reply
:iconpiperinle:
PiperInle Featured By Owner Aug 10, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Stonefur is literally my favorite character!
Reply
:iconbritshpnacake:
Britshpnacake Featured By Owner Aug 1, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
ok



holly leaf
i said i liked her in that one pic
i lied
hollyass
u ass
Reply
:iconkikiwolf678:
kikiwolf678 Featured By Owner Jul 31, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
i like stonefur more then hollyleaf. She annoys me. 
Reply
:iconpasteldog:
PastelDog Featured By Owner Jul 12, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
I love Hollyleaf (I honestly love the "bitchy" and "rude" personality.) However, Stonefur was a better and more helpful cat. I would pick Stonefur over Hollyleaf anyday.
Reply
:iconcookiestarisakitty:
Cookiestarisakitty Featured By Owner Jul 31, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
same
Reply
:iconcatlover2976:
Catlover2976 Featured By Owner Jul 6, 2015
Hollyleaf just ended up with issues, but she was a hero in the end, but Stonefur was a better hero.
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Jul 7, 2015  Student Filmographer
She jumped in front of one cat who could have easilly jumped out of the way. Plus, Ivypool could have kicked Hawkfrost's ass.
Reply
:iconfiower-dashie:
fIower-dashie Featured By Owner Jun 22, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
*Prepares for hate*

I like Hollyleaf ;3;
Reply
:iconharryfly:
Harryfly Featured By Owner Jul 19, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
That's an opinion, nobody could hate on you for that! ^^
Reply
:iconspottedspeckle6464:
spottedspeckle6464 Featured By Owner Jun 12, 2015
well it might be because holly was mentioned more but I still like Stonefur and Hollyleaf
Reply
:iconirishnosey:
IrishNosey Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2015  Student Digital Artist
I HATE HOLLYLEAF OK WTF SHE WASNT EVEN KIND JUST BECAUSE THE ERINS DIDNT WANT HER DEATH TO BE MEANINGLESS SO THEY DIDNT LET HER DIE IN THE TUNNELS BUT THOUGHT,,

"hey lets give er a heroic death because even though she has been an ass and done nothing but cause shit, let her do one final act and everything is forgiven!"
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Jun 5, 2015  Student Filmographer
AMEN
Reply
:iconkraving4games:
Kraving4games Featured By Owner May 7, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Lol hollybitch
Reply
:iconilovecat3434:
Ilovecat3434 Featured By Owner May 7, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
I will always wonder why people like Hollyleaf.
She's annoying as fuck omfg
Reply
:iconlnspector:
lnspector Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2015
Both are completely different characters in completely different situations bruh
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Mar 31, 2015  Student Filmographer
bruh
Reply
:icono53:
O53 Featured By Owner Edited Feb 15, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
I never really got to the books where HollyLeaf comes up and dies.

So let me get this straight. She threatens her mother with deathberries.
She took her adoptive news badly, and got super butthurt by it.
So then she takes it out on Ashfur, because he happened to have known this beforehand and when he thought of telling, she just sorta decides to murder him and then all of a sudden scream out the news at a gathering?
Then, she saved Ivypool, and died.

She saved one cat.

And that counts as a heroic death to everybody.

I'm gonna.
Reply
:iconplease-i-love:
Please-i-love Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2015  Student Artist
I do understand why she killed Ashfur though, because he tried to kill her and her siblings but it still doesn't make that much sense.
couldn't they like talk about it
Reply
:iconirishnosey:
IrishNosey Featured By Owner Jun 4, 2015  Student Digital Artist
But you also have to remember ashfur said during the fire scene that he would let holly, jay and lion go because they werent squirrels kits, he wanted squirrel to suffer no other cat so as soon as he found out they were hers then he suddenly thought
"oh ok its cool you three can go" and i could help but feel that him and the three had something common in that moment, hate for squirrel.

during the firescene holly was scared and as soon as the secret was revealed she was mega pissed at squirrel and when ash ran off she wasnt angry at him, she was moody and shouldnt have killed him. 
Reply
:icono53:
O53 Featured By Owner Mar 30, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist

Like.
Words before actions would be nice at least.
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Feb 16, 2015  Student Filmographer
:iconclapplz:
Reply
:icono53:
O53 Featured By Owner Feb 16, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
//bows//
Reply
:iconepicrandomcat115:
EpicRandomCat115 Featured By Owner Feb 15, 2015  Hobbyist General Artist
Holyleaf comes back from the tunnels and forgives leafpool when she is about to die at the end of the last hope.
Reply
:iconcatffood:
CatFfood Featured By Owner Feb 8, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Um Sontefur actually got mad and refused to believe her.
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Feb 9, 2015  Student Filmographer
i know, but he did ultimately forgive her like a mature adult would. Hollyleaf never even said sorry.
Reply
:iconaiiygator:
aIIygator Featured By Owner Feb 24, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Firestar had to say something in order for Stonefur to forgive her.
Reply
:iconcatffood:
CatFfood Featured By Owner Feb 9, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
Ya, but he did try to kill his mother.
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Feb 9, 2015  Student Filmographer
Because their clans were at war. He and Mistyfoot ended up sparing Bluestar and helped her out of the river when the dogs attacked.

Hollyleaf threatened to force feed her mother, in her own clan, deathberries and never apologized and never gave any form of gesture to imply that she was sorry.
Reply
:iconcatffood:
CatFfood Featured By Owner Feb 10, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
True Hollyleaf did do that, but actually Firestar/heart and Graystripe attacked them and they were forced to retreat. It was also Leopardstar's order.
Reply
:iconpikachuwarrior:
PikachuWarrior Featured By Owner Jun 20, 2015  Hobbyist Digital Artist
Stonefur was already dead before Fireheart/star and Graystripe rescued them :/
Reply
:iconelusiveblaze:
ElusiveBlaze Featured By Owner Feb 11, 2015  Student Filmographer
True, I haven't read Warriors in a very long time, but Mistyfoot and Stonefur did in the end forgive Bluestar, maturely realising that what she did was for the best.
Hollyleaf's just a poorly written, angsty Sue.
Reply
:iconcatffood:
CatFfood Featured By Owner Feb 12, 2015  Hobbyist Traditional Artist
I agree that Holyleaf was a Sue, but she ended up forgiving her mother. Just as Stonefur had.
Reply
Add a Comment:
 
×




Details

Submitted on
July 9, 2013
Image Size
515 KB
Resolution
864×2478
Link
Thumb
Embed

Stats

Views
10,782 (7 today)
Favourites
453 (who?)
Comments
402
Downloads
12
×